How Do You Make French Toast?
What do you actually need to make French toast?
The short answer is bread, eggs, milk, and fat. Everything else is seasoning. A workable ratio is one egg to about a quarter cup of milk for every two slices, so scale up in that pattern and you will not end up with leftover custard or dry bread.
Salt matters more than people expect. A pinch in the custard keeps the egg from tasting flat, and a little sugar helps browning. Vanilla, cinnamon, or nutmeg are optional but common.
- Bread: slightly stale, thick sliced
- Eggs: the base of the custard
- Milk: whole milk gives the richest result, but any milk works
- Salt and sugar: small amounts, big difference
- Butter or oil: for the pan
Why does stale bread make better French toast?
Fresh bread is already full of moisture, so it has little room to absorb custard and tends to fall apart. Bread that has dried out a bit acts like a sponge. If all you have is a fresh loaf, leave the slices out for an hour or toast them lightly first.
How long should you soak the bread?
Seconds, not minutes. Dip each side, let the excess drip back into the bowl, and go straight to the pan. Soaking too long is the single most common reason French toast ends up soggy in the middle.
What heat should you cook French toast on?
Medium. Too hot and the outside burns before the egg sets inside. Too cool and the bread slowly absorbs fat and turns greasy. Melt butter, let it foam, then add the bread and give each side a few minutes until deeply golden.
Is French toast actually French?
Not exactly. The dish shows up in Roman cookbooks as pan dulcis, and the name most of Europe uses, French toast included, traces back to an old practice of using up bread that would otherwise go stale. The French call it pain perdu, literally lost bread. So the real answer to how to make French toast is that you are rescuing bread, not showing off.
What should you serve with it?
Maple syrup is the default, but powdered sugar, fresh fruit, or a little butter all work. If you want a savory version, skip the sugar and vanilla and top with cheese or a fried egg instead.