Which vs That: What's the Difference?
People usually mean one of two things here: they want the rule, or they want to know why their spell checker keeps flagging them. Both come down to one question. Is the clause essential to the sentence, or is it a bonus?
What is the difference between which and that?
A that clause narrows things down. It tells the reader which one you mean, so the sentence needs it. A which clause adds commentary on something already identified, so it usually sits after a comma and could be lifted out without breaking the sentence.
That is why the comma is the tell. If the clause is essential, no comma and usually that. If it is extra, comma and which.
When should you use that instead of which?
Reach for that when removing the clause would leave the reader unsure what you are talking about.
- The bike that has the red seat is mine. (There are several bikes. This one is mine.)
- The report that landed on Friday needs edits. (Which report? That one.)
No comma goes before that. If you see a comma there, something has gone sideways.
When should you use which instead of that?
Use which when the thing is already clear and the clause just adds a fact about it.
- The bike, which has a red seat, is mine. (One bike, already known. The seat color is a detail.)
- The report, which landed on Friday, needs edits. (The report is identified. Friday is extra.)
Same words, different meaning. In the first version, the red seat identifies your bike. In the second, it is just a fact.
Which vs that: examples side by side
| Sentence | Clause type | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Cars that run on diesel cost more. | Essential | Only diesel cars |
| Cars, which run on diesel, cost more. | Extra | All cars, and they happen to be diesel |
| The book that won the prize sold out. | Essential | One specific book |
| The book, which won the prize, sold out. | Extra | One known book, prize as a bonus |
Is it ever wrong to use which without a comma?
Informal writing lets it slide, and plenty of published prose does it. In careful writing, though, a which with no comma reads as a small stumble. American editing tends to be strict about the that/which split. British usage is looser and often uses which for both jobs.
One fun wrinkle: the word that is also a demonstrative, as in "that bike is mine." Nobody confuses the two in practice, but it explains why the search results get noisy.
What is the fastest way to check?
Delete the clause. If the sentence still says what you mean, use a comma and which. If the meaning collapses into vagueness, use that with no comma.
One more: if the clause follows a preposition, which is the only option. "The house in which I grew up" works. "The house in that I grew up" does not.