What Are This or That Questions?
What Are This or That Questions, Exactly?
They are forced-choice questions: two options, one pick, no explaining your way out. The whole appeal is that you have to commit. Where a Would You Rather question asks you to imagine an absurd scenario, This or That sticks to everyday preferences and small trade-offs, which makes it easier to answer and harder to fake.
People usually mean one of two things here. Either they want the rules for the party game, or they want a list of prompts to use right now.
How Do You Play This or That?
There is no official rulebook, which is part of why it travels well.
- Rapid fire: one person reads prompts and everyone shouts or points to a side of the room.
- Point to the side: mark one wall A and one wall B, then people move to their answer.
- Written quiz: everyone writes answers, then compares and scores who matches.
- Couples and friends: one person guesses the other's pick, then you reveal and keep score.
The only real rule: no answering both, and no explaining until everyone has picked.
What Are Some Good This or That Questions?
Food and drink prompts land fastest with any group.
| Option A | Option B |
|---|---|
| Pizza | Tacos |
| Coffee | Tea |
| Sweet breakfast | Savory breakfast |
| Ice cream cone | Ice cream cup |
For a group that already knows each other, push toward values and habits: night owl or early bird, text or call, big party or small dinner, road trip or flight, rent forever or buy far away. The mild ones warm people up. The pointed ones, like save the money or spend it, are where the arguments start.
Why Do These Questions Get So Heated?
Because a forced choice exposes a priority. Someone who picks mountains over beach is telling you they value quiet over crowds, or effort over ease, whether they mean to or not. That is also why the format shows up in personality quizzes and compatibility tests. It is a fast way to compare two people without a long conversation.
One small delight: the format is older than the internet. Forced-choice pairs have been used in psychology surveys for decades, and the party version is basically that idea with snacks.
What Should You Avoid?
Skip prompts where one answer is obviously the "right" one, and skip anything that pokes at real insecurities about bodies, money, or family. The fun comes from low stakes. Keep the trade-offs silly or small and the group will keep playing.