Share:

  • Facebook
  • Hacker News

Follow:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
Chris Cardell

Western Digital 1TB My Book Review

Back in December of 2007 we purchased the USB version of Western Digital’s My Book Essential Edition 1TB external hard drive for £159.99 from Amazon. Since then the price has dropped to £89.98. Ouch.

Western Digital My Book EssentialHaving always purchased Western Digital hard drives and never seeing any disk or cable failures it becomes difficult to understand how so many people see these drives fail. Its either pure luck on our part or people are not treating these things correctly. In reality it’s probably a mixture of the two. Issue number one, putting all your eggs in one basket, one terabyte is still a significant amount of data. If you have the desk space and an extra socket it may be smarter to spread the risk and purchase two 500GB hard drives for a similar price.

Almost 11 months have passed problem free, the drive looks great, its very quiet, fast and we get 931.5GB of actual storage. The software that comes with device is fairly abysmal, as long as your computer is relatively new (less than 8 years old) it should work out the box without the need to install any software or drivers.

On Amazon you might find some odd reviews and some plain untrue, this one probably slots into the ‘odd’ category. Ms. S. Johnson explained how her 6-month-old hard drive failed,

“Apart from the occasional rebooting of explorer from this ‘My Book’ I thought well that’s a quirk – today there was a bump it jumped about an inch in the air (NOTE – IT JUMPED BY ITSELF – I did not knock it – the inertia of the internal failure was that bad).”

Mr. R. C. Dawson stated,

“If you use Mac, do not buy a Western Digital Drive. It will not partition and cannot be reformatted for Mac. There are tutorials available trying to solve this. They do not work. WD support is useless. The drive is a waste of time and money. Avoid.”

This statement simply isn’t true. Our drive is formatted with NTFS and is fully readable by our Mac Pro. Mac doesn’t come with the ability to write to NTFS out the box. However software is readily available that allows you to write to NTFS as well as read from it.

Although our experiences have shown Western Digital to be only a shining beacon of reliability (our 250GB WD external hard drive purchased June 2005 works as if new) there seems to be an overwhelming number of people who would disagree.

Beware when purchasing hard drives, due to moving parts they will never be 100% reliable.

This entry was posted on Sunday, November 16th, 2008 at 7:23 pm GMT. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.



Quick links

Print | Email this story

You might also like

    None Found
  • http://doeswhat.com DoesWhat

    Amazon reviewer quotations have been de-capitalized and spelling mistakes have been corrected.

  • den

    I thought 1TB was 1000GB. How come you only get 931.5GB?

  • tim

    because 1 megabyte = 1024kb

  • Paul

    On the Western Digital review it was said they do noy work on MAC I have been running one on mine for over a year. It is one of the last Macs before they went over to Intel. So that may be the reason

  • Rod

    I’ve just started running the 1TB WD MyBook Essential on my MACPRO and it is working great. My only issue is that I need to use the external as a drive and not as a back up only. I need to run the system and plug-ins only on the main HD and save files on the WD.

    How can I accomplish this? Anyone?

Most Popular


Recent Articles



What is the biggest hurdle you have faced or are still facing?

The biggest hurdle is finding talented developers who have the drive and desire to see the success of ‘your baby’ as much as you do. Often times...
Benjamin Trotter (Storefront Social)

Benjamin Trotter
Storefront Social

What do you wish you’d have known ten years ago that you know now?

Managing multiple products is like managing multiple businesses at once. It is much easier to do this later than...
Shalin Jain (HappyFox)

Shalin Jain
HappyFox

What made you decide to start working on JobGizmo?

The idea of a job hunt organizer came to me back in 2005. I was in a continuing education program, trying to expand my web programming...
Avery Smith (JobGizmo)

Avery Smith
JobGizmo

What was the most challenging part of developing Safestacks?

Time. Safestacks started as a side project and took two years to build as we balanced our own client work. Moving away from...
Jeff Teschke (Safestacks)

Jeff Teschke
Safestacks